Hall of Fame
2024
- Merrell Clark, Class of 1956
- Orren Knauer, Class of 1957
- Cindy Hess, Class of 1990
- Matt Baldwin, Class of 1997
- Caroline Barry, Class of 2011
- Lauren Stauffer, Class of 2012
- Tyler Karpinski, Class of 2013
2023
- Reilly Gearhart, Class of 2016
- Kristine Harclerode-King, Class of 2003
- Kim Harclerode, Class of 2005
- Mark Linn, Coach
- David Nguyen, Class of 1995
- Lacy Smith, Class of 2015
2022
- Laura Werner Kesy, Class of 2002
- Jodie Briner Kramer, Class of 1992
- Devon Schneider, Class of 2012
- Tim Stratton, Class of 2007
- Mike Zell, Coach
2021
- COVID
2020
- Dave Ammon, Class of 1989
- Jon Benchich, Class of 1991
- Ashley Warner Evans, Class of 1994
- Cam Gallagher, Class of 2011
- Tom Legath, Class of 1996
2019
- Dan DeMasters, Class of 2004
- Alexandria Leslie, Class of 2014
- Matt Grossman, Class of 2014
2018
- Jaclyn Poucel, Class of 2011
- Nick Plack, Class of 1997
- Skip Walters, Coach
2017
- Molly Hendrick, Class of 2013
- Ben Scheetz, Class of 2008
- Jesse Meredith, Class of 2002
- Bud Roderick, Friend of Athletics
2016
- Kiersten Green, Class of 2011
- Sarah Bejgrowicz, Class of 2007
- Zarek Valentin, Class of 2009
2015
- George Eager, Class of 2005
- Lauren Sindall, Class of 2005
- Austin Gallagher, Class of 2007
- Raymond N. Myer, Class of 1940
2014
- Tom Daily, Class of 1969
- Carl Drukenbrod, Class of 1952
- Pete Glass, Class of 1966
- State Relay Swim Champions, Class of 1962
2013
- Bob Belser, Class of 1983
- Pat Bostick, Class of 2007
- Scott Goebel, Class of 1983
- Brad Miller, Class of 2006
2012
- David J. Eckhart, Class of 1974
- Craig Miller, Class of 2006
- Geoffrey B. Miller, Class of 1972
2011
- Megan Brown, Class of 1995
- Michael P Eckhart, Class of 1974
- Fred Levin, Class of 1964
2010
- Jeff Duke, Class of 1971
- Kristen Erb McKenna, Class of 1997
- Matt Woolley, Class of 1989
2009
- Greg Duke, Class of 1974
- Pamela Engroff Dochter, Class of 1971
- Wilson K. Lewars Jr., Coach
- 1972 Rifle Team, Team
2008
- Rod Barthe, Class of 1971
- Ken Kauffman, Class of 1969
- Bill Rohrbach, Class of 1969
2007
- Robert Brandt III, Class of 1998
- Anita Plakans, Class of 1986
- Christopher Yingling, Class of 1999
2006
- Ethel J. Armstrong, Class of 1959
- Wes Kintner, Class of 1995
- Jenny Stumpf Sassaman, Class of 1988
2005
- George Greiner, Class of 1955
- Ed Journey, Class of N/A
- R.E. "Mac" McNickle, Friend of Athletics
- Pam Mattson Wegert, Class of 1981
2004
- Michael Baird, Class of 1999
- Robert Kintner, Class of 1993
- Patti Kadel Maurer, Class of 1970
- Pete Shellenberger, Class of 1997
2003
- Dan Bare, Coach
- Brooke Gilliford, Class of 1998
- King Knox, Class of 1960
- Ed Plakans, Class of 1989
2002
- Scott K. Kelly, Class of 1984
- Donald H. Kliewer, Class of 1953
- Edwin G. Miller, Class of 1946
- Karen Sheehan, Class of 1988
- Jim Strathmeyer, Class of 1972
2001
- C. Wendell Hower, Class of 1972
- Bill Kabasenche, Class of 1991
- Steve Kelly, Class of 1981
- Bridget Stamp Ruiz, Class of 1994
- Stan Solodky, Class of 1969
2000
- Charlotte Atwater-Miller, Class of 1967
- Chester Grill, Class of 1939
- Gordie Groome, Coach
- Paul Kruis , Class of 1972
- Kathianne Sellers, Class of 1992
1999
- Dan Blakinger, Class of 1970
- Todd Bushnell, Class of 1969
- Lew Ireland, Class of 1957
- Jen McKonly, Class of 1992
- Stacy Gilburg Rucci, Class of 1988
- Clarence Watson, Class of 1949
1998
- Missy Eavenson, Class of 1983
- Elizabeth Giering Hetrick, Class of 1985
- Jim Kruis, Class of 1974
- Paul L. Wenrich, Coach
- Ken Whisler, Coach
1997
- Kenneth N. Barshinger, Class of Coach
- Joseph Glass, Class of 1962
- Christian H. Hess, Friend of Athletics
- Cathy Belser McBride, Class of 1986
- Christian H. Martin Jr., Class of 1946
1996
- John H. Emich, Class of 1936
- Bob Funk, Class of 1965
- Jim Furyk, Class of 1988
- Glenn E. Gallagher, Class of 1978
- Jane Glass, Class of 1974
- Jay Hollinger, Class of 1948
- Gene Kruis, Coach
- Del Warfel, Class of 1955